GOOD THINGS COME IN TWOS

$64.00

 

Even up the Pantry with 2 of each flavor.   It's all about balance with this one!  Because you never know which one you feel like any day of the week.

MARINARA - classic, perfect on its own or add some protein and make it fancy in 5 minutes!  Use as the base of any dish from Lasagne to Parmigiana, and taste how much it elevates your recipe

ARRABBIATA - just the right amount of spice for when you need a little kick.  

VODKA -for those times when a little decadence is called for.  Date night, meeting the in-laws, bestie's bday.  You've got this!

 ****All sauces are certified organic and kosher 

Even up the Pantry with 2 jars of each flavor. It's all about balance with this one! Because you never know which one you feel like any day of the week.

A great Marinara sauce is a base for everything!  Our Marinara is made from sweet tomatoes so it needs no added sugar, its much lower in fat than the leading brands and uses organic everything, with the best extra virgin olive oil.  But what is most important -  the taste!

A delicious sauce with just the right amount of spice, slow-simmered with the best tomatoes, herbs, onions, and garlic.  No need for added sugar or loads of fat - the taste is in the organic ingredients and Pizza Girls' family recipe!

This one is decadence.  Date night, meet the in-laws, home-schooling kids - you need a treat!  Stir it through your favorite pasta - or make one of our yummy recipes in a couple of minutes.   It elevates your meal above and beyond and is a definite crowd-pleaser.

The Sauce is Everything

Elevated authentic Italian family recipes to satisfy and uplift the ideals of a new generation of home cooks.

Classic Marinara

Marinara

Our Marinara sauce bursts with natural sweetness, organic goodness, and the purest extra virgin olive oil!

SHOP NOW

Spicy Marinara

Arrabbiata Sauce

Boldly spiced and slow-simmered, our sauce highlights organic tomatoes and herbs—no sugar or fat!

SHOP NOW

Creamy Vodka Marinara

Vodka Sauce

Pure decadence! Perfect for date nights or family dinners—just stir into pasta and enjoy!

SHOP NOW

I made my own sauce...

It was so hard to find organic sauces that had no added sugar or unnecessary additives - and there wasn’t a single jar that represented the moms of my generation. Us millennial moms care about every single ingredient but still want that high quality taste, with a fresh spin on packaging."

Caroline D'Amore, Founder

Customer Reviews

Based on 447 reviews
90%
(403)
4%
(16)
3%
(13)
1%
(4)
2%
(11)
S
Sharon Galan
Wish it were as spicy as before

I love the product. I’ve ordered all of the various sauces. I’ve given them as gifts. I’m pretty devout; however, when the spicy sauce used to be called, “Arrabbiata sauce “ it was indeed spicy. Now….it’s….not really. Bummer. I will still continue to be a loyal customer because the product is good and I’ve never had an issue with delivery. I just personally love spicy and this one sauce changed (in my opinion). This 3 star review is only based on the new “spicy marinara.” In general the sauces are a solid five stars.

M
Mark

Pleasantly surprised with the regular sauce. Very good. Cant wait to try the others. Inwaited so long begore buying. I wish i hadnt.

F
Faith Viola
Christmas 2025

Cannot not review at this time.
Haven’t opened it yet

A
Angela Hannibal
So cool!

I’m hooked! Not only are the grills adorable, but they make the pizzas taste amazing. I’m never baking a pizza in my regular oven again!

S
Stephen Bitter

THE ALL-SPICY 6 PACK