Reviews

Based on 44 reviews
89%
(39)
7%
(3)
5%
(2)
0%
(0)
0%
(0)
L
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Laurie Scantlebury
Awesome sauce!

Tried the arrabiatta sauce and it has amazing flavor. I didn't even have to add any additional seasoning. Thank you!

d
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
debra jacobs

Love it. It tastes as if it was just made. For a jar sauce, that’s impressive.

Best Sauces Ever

These are the best pasta sauces, period! So easy to use and versatile. All 3 varieties are amazing. We now look forward to pasta nights because of these sauces. Perfect and easy for any weeknight meals and they taste fancy enough for special occasions too. Definitely my pantry essentials!

Good Stuff!

Authentic Italian, love the variety, Pizza Girl story is what made me check the product and it’s now one of my favorites ❤️

Quality sauce

Very good just wish was a bit spicier

Great sauce! Excellent with pasta

I will be ordering again! Thank you guys for awesome pasta sauce!

THE ULTIMATE VODKA SAUCE PARTY - 6 PACK

C
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Caryn Bettencourt

Have not tried any of the sauce yet...it is a Christmas gift...I also sent an email that the box was a gift to my husband who came home and saw it on the porch which ruined the surprise because your box that you sent said pizza girl all over it and he knew at that point it was a gift...I was a little upset about it and your response was sorry about that...oh well no surprise now...

Best Pasta Sauce!!

I have tried all the sauces and love each one. Went with just the PG Marinara (6) this time, then will stock up on the others.
Each one is made with natural products and lots of love. Each have such flavor. And like Isabella, Pizza Girl Sauce tastes so good right out of the jar too. Hope to see on our shelves in PA in near future.

L
PIZZA GIRL'S PANTRY COMBO 6 PACK
Laura McCauley GREGORY
Yummo! ❤️

Best sauce ever! I am adding a jar or 3 to everyone’s Christmas gift this year! Even love eating it straight from the jar! ❤️🎄❤️

The best sauce ever!

This is the best sauce ever and we have tried every gourmet sauce on the market. It's the only sauce my husband and I agree on. We actually ship it to Portland!

r
THE VEGAN PACK
rob king
love this sauce !!

i am a repeat customer and will continue to only use pizza girl sauce. this is the best tasting red sauce i have ever had. healthy ingredients and great flavor are a rare combination. love both the marinara and spicier arrabiata sauces. this is a company that takes great pride in their products. shipping containers and packaging are top notch. 5 stars all around from me !!

m
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
margaret daley
expensive but good

Love all the flavors a little pricey though

Hi Margaret

Thanks for your review. We are so happy you love the flavors - and we hear you on the price . If you buy a 3 pack we have to add a shipping cost (which we share with you) as shipping in glass jars is costly . We offer the 6 packs and pay the shipping and there is also an option to subscribe so you can have a box sent every month or two for even more discount . We have tried hard to devise a model that works - because truthfully after paying for slow cooking and true organic ingredients plus the high shipping costs there’s very little left to cover our costs. True story - and very common with small companies like ours . Thanks for trying us and we appreciate the opportunity to explain a little bit more about our company.

C
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Christopher Schlumpberger
Best Sauce You Can Buy!!

Don’t think, just buy it!! 😍

My Pantry Essentials!

Love all the flavors in this 3 pack sampler! Easy to use and so delicious. These are my new party favorites and essentials now. Can't wait to share them with my friends and family. I know they will love the clean and healthy ingredients list too.

My new favorite

I absolutely adore these sauces! The labels are so cute & perfectly me. Cute packaging always helps! Now as for the sauce…I feel it’s the ABSOLUTE BEST SAUCE MADE RIGHT NOW. I love no funky ingredients or sugar or high fructose corn syrup. I can’t say enough great things. Plus Caroline is simply beautiful. A down to earth cool girl who I think is perfection. Definitely give all of them a try! The marinara is probably my fav but it’s hard to decide they’re THAT good.

S
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Stacey Anderson
Awesome

We have had the vodka sauce,”OMG” and the marinara sauce, both were so yummy. I look forward to cooking with the arrabbiata sauce, I’m sure it’s going to be just as fabulous as the other two.
I will definitely be ordering more soon!

M
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Meredith McNamee

So flavorful! Each was a delight and I’m so glad I purchased all three to try them. Yum!

L
GOOD THINGS COME IN TWOS
Laura McCauley GREGORY
Best sauce..❤️❤️❤️

Absolutely LOVE this stuff! Perfect for SO many of my favorites..taking it to the next level! Stocking up!! ❤️❤️❤️

Best secret sauce sold in America!!

Being a fan of The Hills we discovered this brand. I ordered the 6 pack combo as sort of a joke. However they are NO JOKE!! So far we have used the vodka sauce for spaghetti and the marinara for home made pizza. Both were absolutely delicious. Bold, full of flavor and almost seemed as if it was and not out of a jar.

A
THE VEGAN PACK
Amy Straub

I don’t eat any sugar so I ordered your sauces. One of them is kind of bland and the other a little spicy so I combine them which makes it perfect. The only criticism I have is that they are too watery. I like my sauces thicker. Not sure I would get them again. Still on the fence. I do wish your company great success!

Extremely Flavorful!

I wasn’t sure what to expect, but the flavor of the sauce is incredible. It tastes so fresh, a perfect blend of spices and tomatoes. As my Papa Jim would say, “it taste like more."

Best Pizza sauce I’ve ever tried

Purchased the pantry pack, and was able to try all 3 since. These are the best sauces I’ve ever had. The Arrabbiata and Vodka were my favorite, but still love the marinara as well. Would love if you did a 6 pack that had 3 of the Arrabbiata and 3 vodka!

Will be buying this again every time I need sauce

Sassy Sauce is beyond suitable

Devouring this healthy sauce jar by jar
Eggplant getting lathered up; Bowtie equally tossed for a complete bite of 😋
That’s all

Packed well and absolutely delicious! Thank you!