Reviews

Based on 154 reviews
86%
(133)
6%
(9)
5%
(8)
1%
(1)
2%
(3)

I just loved this sauce and coming in twos is worth it cause then you can feed as many as you like Still trying the marinara and love the vodka sauce

Well Worth the Wait

These sauces were part of a birthday gift for my mom, with whom I enjoyed cheering Caroline on during FOOD STARS. We really loved the zestiness of the marinara, and the vodka sauce was a beautiful complement to a gnocchi dish we prepared. My mom normally is not crazy about spicy, but even she loved the arrabbiata sauce. Brava!

GOOD THINGS COME IN TWOS

R
GOOD THINGS COME IN TWOS
Roxanne Neatherlin
amazing!!

The spicy one is my favorite! i will continue buying! i even bought my daughter and Daughter in law all 3

Great sauce

Loved the sauce. Great favor. Will definitely order more.

G
THE ALL-SPICY 6 PACK
Gary Antonucci
XLNT but…..

The arrabbiata Pasta Sauce is XLNT but 2 bottles arrived totally broken so I had to clean off the other 4 bottles as sauce was everywhere 😟

C
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Christy Loftin
Great Sauce!!

This is absolutely the best pasta sauce I've ever had from a jar! I love the use of organic ingredients and the different flavors. I think the Vodka sauce is my fav but they are all AWESOME!

Superb

Oh, I was pleasantly surprised as to how good this taste. I can’t wait to try another brand, but the marinara is very good.

Great Sauce

We've tried all your varieties and found them to be excellent in flavor and in consistency! Delicious over pasta! (I'm Italian-American from Brooklyn, NY)

I
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Isaac Livingston
Excellent Sauce

We really enjoyed the sauces and will be ordering more !! Thank you !!

Great sauce

Very tasty - will buy again

Just tried it

Just tried the marinara last night. Very tasty. Looking forward to the other varieties.

H
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Holly Patterson
Delivery Time

The sauce is great but from the order date to when I received the product, the delivery was very slow!! I wanted these for a dinner and did not get them quick enough.

Best Pasta Sauce !!

I was skeptical at first.. I used the sauce the day I received it. Oh my !! It was the best tasting sauce I ever had.. I did ordered another six pack and will continue buying your delicious sauce...Thank you !!!

S
GOOD THINGS COME IN TWOS
Stephanie Clark
Amazing sauce!

It taste so fresh and was delicious !The Vodka sauce was my favorite!

e
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
elissa greene
ok

didn't receive a variety pack due to b/o but it needs more seasoning.

Marinara

I thought it was fine. I was disappointed because I was excited to get the product, but didn't think it was anything special and very over-priced.

BEST EVER

GREAT no other better prefect blend love this sauce.

Amazing! Mouth Watering! Delicious!

Absolutely amazing sauces! Can't speak highly enough about them. I live on Colorado and really hope for Pizza Girl to be on the shelves soon. I'll be ordering more in the mean time :)
(writing this review is actually making me hungry and wanting more Pizza Girl sauce)

Thank you so much :)

1st time buying. Very Good

I ordered six jars. I thought I was getting 2 of each flavor. I only got one Vodka sauce and 3 marinara.
I have used 2 of the marinara sauce. Very very good.

love this sauce !!

i must disclose up front, i am a monthly buyer of this delicious yet healthy sauce. until pizza girl, using 'delicious & healthy' in the same sentence to describe a pasta sauce was an oxymoron. this sauce truly is both !!! i love it !!!

M
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Meredith Ulino
Modified 3-pack sampler

We originally ordered the 3-pack sampler, but due to significant delays, we were offered a modified version that could ship faster. So we went with that, and received 2 Marinara & 1 Vodka. So far we’ve only sampled the Marinara, and we really enjoyed it. We had intentions of “doctoring it up” as most jarred sauces require, but this was delicious straight out of the jar. Unheard of (in my opinion) with other jarred pasta sauces. Looking forward to trying the Vodka sauce very soon!

L
THE 3 PACK SAMPLER
Linda Sherlock

Good afternoon. I opened and used the vodka sauce first. Little too much onions for me but other than that I enjoyed the sauce with my pasta, with parmesan cheese and some Ricotta. Perfect meal. I am glad I saw you on chef Ramsey contest. I usually don’t order on line but I’m glad I did order the sample pack. Thank you 😊

Sorry Not Worth It!

Honestly I don't think its worth the price. When I still have to heavily season it to have some flavor, I would rather just buy Wegmans brand, Ragu or Prego.

Sorry this wasn't to your taste! Pizza Girl has worked hard to create a healthier, tastier sauce with less salt and fat - so the result is very different if you are used to jarred sauces like Prego - but we understand each person has their own benchmarks. Thanks for trying!